| Stock Return
Analysis (Level 1 Template) Let's do
an analysis on Johnson & Johnson, the health care product
company. After having done some research on the company (its
products, competitors, and so on), you are ready to crunch
some numbers. (For an example of an Australian company,
click here.)
| 
|
This is where the Valuesoft
Investment System comes in.
Suppose you are interested in estimating
the percentage return on buying JNJ now and holding
it for 5 years. You will need some data which
you can get get free from most of the major investment
sites such as
Money Central or Yahoo
Finance. When you use these sites, you may have
to go to different pages to collect all the information
that you need.
For Yahoo Finance all the data we
need is on the Summary page and the Analyst Estimates
page for each company. The URL for these pages for
Johnson and Johnson are: |
You might find it easiest to print these pages before you
start. The following is the list of the required data and
the page where you can find it. (More details of these terms
can be found in our glossary: click
here. For the financial glossary at Yahoo, click
here.)
Current price:
this is the last price at which the stock was sold (Profile
page)
Earnings per share (EPS):
the total earnings of the company divided by the number
of shares outstanding (profile page). Think of this as the
amount of money that the company is earning on your behalf
for each share that you own (Profile page).
Price to earnings ratio (P/E
ratio): the current price divided by the earnings
per share (Profile page).
Projected growth rate of earnings:
this is a forecast of the average growth rate of earnings.
Use the figure in the column "Next 5 Years" on
the Analysts Estimates page even though you may have a longer
time frame in mind. If you are not given a figure (perhaps
because no analysts are following the company), enter the
average percentage growth rate for the past 5 years. If
this is also missing, then beware of investing in this company.
With less than five years of data, it is very difficult
to make any forecasts. (In the Level
2 Templates you will see how to avoid having to rely
on analyst forecasts.)
Years: the time frame
of your investment. Generally this will be 5 years or more.
Payout rate: this is
the percentage of earnings that the company pays out in
dividends. You can get this figure at the Key Statistics
page, under the 'Dividends & Splits' table. You can
also calculate it by dividing Dividend by Earnings per Share.
For example, if the dividends are $1.66 and the EPS is $3.51,
then the payout ratio is 1.66 / 3.51= 47.3%. (Even simpler
is to type "= 1.66 / 3.51" in the appropriate
cell and Excel will do the calculation for you.)
For things like the P/E ratio and the projected
growth rate, don't worry too much about decimal places. It
is likely that you will change them to more conservative figures
when you have everything all set up.
The last two requirements are:
Tax rate on
dividends: this is your marginal rate of tax.
Tax rate on capital gains:
for simplicity I will set these at 0% in the following examples.
When you have done this you get the following
numbers.
| Johnson
& Johnson May 30, 2007 |
Current
Price |
EPS |
P/E
Ratio |
Projected
Growth |
Years |
Payout
Rate |
Tax
Div's |
Tax
Capital |
| 63.05 |
3.51 |
17.98 |
8.3% |
5 |
47.3% |
0% |
0% |
Now enter this data into an Excel page to get
something like shown in the following figure:

I have formatted some of the cells as percentages.
Otherwise you can leave them as decimals.
In the cell I3 type =STRETD(A4,B4,C4,D4,E4,F4,G4,H4)
and press return. (You don't need to use uppercase letters.
And if you are more familiar with Excel, you can get the same
result by using the function button and going to the function
STRETD, which stands for STock RETurn with Dividends reinvested.)
When you have done this you will get:

In this case I have formatted the cell I3 as
a percentage. If you did not do this you would get a decimal
number. In this case I have put the cursor back into cell
I3. Notice that =STRETD(A4,B4,C4,D4,E4,F4,G4,H4) has appeared
in a box at the top of the page.
The number 11.17% is an estimate of the before-tax
annual return by purchasing JNJ for $63.05 and holding it
for 5 years.
At the time of writing this, Valueline estimated
that the 3 to 5 year return for JNJ would be in the range
12% to 18% per year so you can see that the figures are similar.
The huge advantage of Valuesoft is that you can put in your
own estimates of the P/E ratio so that you can see exactly
the effect on the final result. We will demonstrate this below.
The other major benefit of valuesoft is cost: around $75 instead
of thousands of dollars.
Of course, the above only works when you have
purchased and loaded Valuesoft. Without Valuesoft, you will
get the result #NAME?
Margin of Safety
Remember, none of the inputs can be totally accurate.
It is up to you to adjust them to allow for a margin of safety
and other outcomes of your investigations. (In the Level
2 Templates we show how Valuesoft has built-in finctions
for calculating a level of safety as a staring point for your
own margin of safety.)
In the 1999 annual report of Berkshire Hathaway,
Warren Buffett said that he employs "a range of values,
rather than some pseudo-precise figure." With Valuesoft
this is a snap since each time you enter a new number and
press return, the answer is automatically recalculated.
For example, you may think that a projected
P/E ratio of 17.98 is too high so you replace it by 15. Also
you are not sure about the projected growth rate of earnings
so you replace it by 6.0%. Now you get the results:

This time the estimated after-tax return is
5.47% per year. What this means is that under a margin of
safety you will make at least 5.47% per year over the next
5 years. At the same time it leaves the upside open so that
the final return could be much higher.
With more experience, you can do the above in
a few minutes. Once you have set it up for a company, it is
a simple matter to update that data as new information becomes
available.
STRETD is only one of the 25 functions in Valuesoft.
One of my other favorite functions is TARGD. This calculates
the price that you would need to pay to achieve your desired
return. When you do this, you set yourself up to wait until
there is a dip in the price. At that moment you can buy the
stock you want at your price to get your
return.
Click here
to purchase the Valuesoft Investment System.
Click here to
read about the hidden desire of investors.
Level 2 Templates Click
here
|